Introduction: Aging, Voice, and the Margins
Jayne Raisborough and colleagues conducted the study "Reduced to Curtain Twitchers?" in which four UK-based women actors aged fifty to seventy shared their experiences of marginalization within the industry. Participants described being sidelined during rehearsals, encountering assumptions of vocal decline, and experiencing a disconnect between their skills and how the industry perceives them. The phrase "reduced to curtain twitchers" encapsulates how these actors were pushed to the margins, treated as less valuable simply because of their age.
The study reveals that these actors' vocal identities were reshaped not by biological decline but by lack of opportunity. Their voices were silenced by context rather than capacity. This silencing stems from aesthetic bias and entrenched assumptions within casting, directing, and education (Raisborough et al.).
Voice Pedagogy and the Myth of Decline
Voice practitioners such as Kristin Linklater and Patsy Rodenburg emphasize that vocal strength and clarity can be sustained across the lifespan through effective technique. Despite this, many training environments subtly privilege youthful voices—those marked by brightness, ease of projection, and pitch flexibility. Such preferences influence casting and reinforce the perception that older voices are inherently less desirable.
While younger voices are often framed as more adaptable, mature voices are frequently mislabeled as inflexible or limited. In practice, the consistency and control developed over time can signify vocal depth and reliability. Nevertheless, the industry's continued emphasis on youthful versatility perpetuates age-based bias in both training and performance.
Within contemporary vocal pedagogy, youthful voices are often treated as the ideal, favoring agile timbres associated with early-career performers. This standard overlooks the richness, resonance, and control that mature voices can offer. Research on vocal aging, including work by Rodenburg and Jo Estill, suggests that while voices change over time, they do not inherently deteriorate. Instead, many older performers cultivate a more grounded relationship to breath, resonance, and rhythm—qualities that can enhance presence and authority onstage.
Pedagogical approaches that affirm vocal evolution rather than resist it would allow educators to support a wider range of performers. This could include curricular shifts that incorporate mature monologues, highlight performers over the age of forty as models, and prioritize emotional weight and stability alongside flexibility.
Performance Case Study: The Roommate
Jen Silverman's play The Roommate follows two middle-aged women navigating personal transformation. The character Sharon evolves from hesitant to self-assured, and her vocal presence shifts accordingly. This change reflects growth and empowerment—not through sounding younger but through increased confidence and agency.
As Sharon gains assurance, her breath deepens, her pacing steadies, and her articulation becomes more deliberate. These qualities align with principles of vocal release and embodied performance, underscoring voice as a site of personal and psychological transformation.
Beyond its narrative of friendship, The Roommate challenges traditional vocal archetypes associated with middle-aged women. The characters Sharon and Robyn resist easy categorization, moving between pauses, restraint, and vocal expansiveness. Their dialogue offers performers space to explore vocal expression rooted in lived experience rather than age-based stereotypes.
Sharon's vocal development mirrors her psychological journey, progressing from clipped, tentative speech to fuller and more assured tones. This shift is not about reclaiming youth but about embodying agency. Roles like these counter the industry's tendency to flatten middle-aged characters, allowing performers to reclaim vocal nuance as a marker of maturity rather than decline.
Musical Rebirth: Death Becomes Her: The Musical
The stage adaptation Death Becomes Her: The Musical features Megan Hilty and Jennifer Simard in roles that satirize obsession with youth and beauty. Originally portrayed on film by Meryl Streep and Goldie Hawn, these characters are now embodied by performers in their forties and fifties, demonstrating that mature women can lead vocally demanding musical theatre roles.
The production amplifies the satire of the original film by centering performers who exist at an age when women are often marginalized by the industry. Rather than concealing age, the musical celebrates vocal power, precision, and authority. As Isabella Rossellini observes, "People never talk about the freedom, the lightness, that comes with ageing"—a sentiment that resonates strongly within this adaptation.
In the 2024 stage adaptation, casting Hilty and Simard adds an additional layer of commentary to the narrative. Their real-life ages sharpen the show's critique of vanity and cultural fear of aging. Both performers bring established vocal legacies, and their presence reinforces the idea that mature voices are capable of sustaining complex, vocally rigorous material.
Audiences are invited not only to hear their range but to witness performers actively resisting the assumption that musical theatre leads must be young to be viable. The result is a production that is both self-aware and empowering.
More from the "Curtain Twitchers" Study
Participants in Raisborough et al.'s study described experiences of invisibility and devaluation, particularly when auditioning alongside younger actors. Several noted that directors often spoke around them rather than to them, assuming sensibilities of fragility instead of professionalism. Such practices reveal a systemic undervaluing of lived experience, emotional depth, and long-developed vocal skill.
By foregrounding these narratives, the study highlights the need for change not only in casting but also in rehearsal culture, language, and expectation. Addressing these factors is essential to creating more inclusive theatrical spaces.
Conclusion
Theatre stands at a critical juncture in how it values women's voices across the lifespan. By acknowledging the lived experiences of performers over the age of forty, challenging outdated pedagogical assumptions, and embracing roles that reflect age with authenticity, the field can begin to shift its narrative. Age does not diminish vocal worth; it can deepen it. When productions foreground this reality, the stage becomes more inclusive, resonant, and representative of the full spectrum of human experience.
Works Cited
Death Becomes Her: The Musical. Book by Marco Pennette, music and lyrics by Julia Mattison and Noel Carey, Universal Theatrical Group, 2024.
Linklater, Kristin. Freeing the Natural Voice. Drama Book Publishers, 1976.
Raisborough, Jayne, et al. "Reduced to Curtain Twitchers?: Age, Ageism and the Careers of Four Women Actors." Journal of Women and Aging, vol. 34, no. 2, 2022, pp. 246–57, doi.org/10.1080/08952841.2021.1910464.
Rodenburg, Patsy. The Right to Speak: Working with the Voice. 1964. Routledge, 1992.
Rossellini, Isabella. Interview by Guy Lodge. The Guardian, 24 Nov. 2024, www.theguardian.com/film/2024/nov/24/isabella-rossellini-conclave-blue-velvet.
Silverman, Jen. The Roommate. Samuel French, 2015.
Secondary Sources
"'Death Becomes Her' Jennifer Simard Reveals Most Embarrassing On Stage Moment." YouTube, uploaded by The Kelly Clarkson Show, 12 Feb. 2025, youtu.be/lrO_J0S-EXY?si=OUgmAvZUoOU-7r19&t=112.
"Jennifer Simard on Her Killer Role in 'Death Becomes Her' | New York Live TV." YouTube, uploaded by New York Live, 15 Apr. 2025, youtu.be/IdFa1YP0wRg?si=rfRaY9a2U9dLbgY0&t=257.
"Jennifer Simard and Christopher Sieber on Death Becomes Her & Jennifer's Viral 'That Was Rude' Line." YouTube, uploaded by Late Night with Seth Meyers, 3 June 2025, youtu.be/pSaP0s4JXno?si=qjUGrHAVdDpRNWah&t=318.
"Megan Hilty and Jennifer Simard Talk DEATH BECOMES HER." YouTube, uploaded by Broadwaycom, 7 Nov. 2024, youtu.be/nASzBjTaRC4?si=Zz6L9OFsGuVizbT9&t=90.
"Mia Farrow and Patti LuPone on Broadway." YouTube, uploaded by CBS Sunday Morning, 1 Sept. 2024, youtu.be/Zv-YR2QyI3s?si=jfglHps4wh2SClRZ&t=95.
"Mia Farrow and Patti LuPone in The Roommate: Odd Couple, Odder Play – Broadway Review." YouTube, uploaded by US Gossip, 13 Sept. 2024, youtu.be/cM_NtPe34xM?si=x5qi1oySP5LpbLXe.
"Michelle Williams Talks 'Death Becomes Her,' Being in 'Prime of Life.'" YouTube, uploaded by TODAY with Jenna & Sheinelle, 27 May 2025, youtu.be/lXs7c_yTtj0?si=FrNu0OZ4Z9uc0P_D&t=90.
"Michelle Williams Talks 'Death Becomes Her' on Broadway." YouTube, uploaded by Good Morning America, 3 Feb. 2025, youtu.be/9vyzBSuhndw?si=57QPLguPxhtXDBiK.
"Playwright Jen Silverman Talks All Thing[s] The Roommate on Broadway." YouTube, uploaded by The Roommate on Broadway, 10 Sept. 2024, youtu.be/Nrj53XW8ZqE?si=f_9PM2Eghf6MyGlV
PRIME Productions, theatre company in Minneapolis/St. Paul representing voices of women over the age of fifty: www.primeprods.org.